How to Retarget Website Visitors Without Being Annoying

Retargeting can be a great way to bring people back to your website, especially when they were already checking out your services. But as most business owners know, it’s also easy for these ads to cross the line and start feeling pushy. Nobody wants to follow a customer around the internet with the same ad over and over. The goal is to gently remind people you’re there, not make them regret clicking in the first place.

Here’s how to keep your retargeting marketing efforts helpful instead of annoying.

‍

Share Something Useful, Not the Same Old Message

People respond better when the ad actually helps them. Instead of repeating the same headline or “Book Now” button, try offering something that answers a question they might still have. You can add these into your collateral to help make the campaign more effective. For example:

• A quick FAQ that clears up a common hesitation

• A short video showing how your service works

• A customer review they may not have seen

• A helpful resource to send to their email or texts

If the ad gives value, it feels less like advertising and more like a helpful nudge as opposed to being in their face!

‍

Don’t Overdo the Frequency

Seeing your ad once or twice is fine. Seeing it all weekend long, multiple times? That’s when people get irritated. Frequency caps are one of the easiest ways to fix this. A little spacing between impressions helps your ads feel natural instead of overwhelming.

‍

Match the Message to What They Viewed

Not every website visitor is in the same boat. Someone reading your service page is in a very different mindset from someone who clicked your homepage and bounced. Retargeting works better when the message fits their visit. When the ad lines up with where they left off, it feels more like a continuation and less like a cold pitch.

A few examples:

• Did they look at pricing? Show an ad that highlights what makes your service worth every penny!

• Perhaps they visited your services page. Have a carousel style ad that shows your range of services and call-to-action to book/call now.  

• Maybe they checked out a specific service. Share a testimonial about that exact service.

• If they started filling out a form but didn’t finish, a simple reminder ad may be enough.

‍

More Just for You > Best Marketing Channels to Get More Calls

‍

Keep the Tone Friendly and Down-to-Earth

For trades businesses especially, people want to feel like they’re dealing with real humans. Retargeting doesn’t need dramatic wording or pressure tactics. A simple, straightforward message often works best: “Here’s what you might’ve missed,” or “If you have questions, we’re here.”

When retargeting feels natural, people don’t mind seeing it. The goal is to be visible (in a good way).

‍

Retargeting That Works

Remember, retargeting isn’t about chasing people. It’s about showing up at the perfect moment with the right information. When you give your audience space, share something useful, and tailor your message, retargeting becomes a natural part of your marketing, not a nuisance. We want to build trust, not frustration.

If you want help building retargeting that feels the way real customers appreciate, our team at My Marketing Works can walk you through the strategy that works your business. Reach out to us today!

‍